As a reporter at the Express at that time, I was one of those fortunate ones to benefit from the changes he brought about. They have to be dealt with," Shourie says. The Indian Express stories regularly sparked off a furore in Parliament, compelling the government to respond. Model Question and Answer on S.34, 10 and 17 of the Evidence Act. They avoid taking them to parks and restaurants, fearing stares. Nobody believes the Rs 1 lakh crore (stimulus) figure. What, in your view, is the way forward? For instance, the deficit should not exceed 3.3 or 4 per cent of the GDP. Goenkas colourful language, replete with expletives and imagery, has been reproduced by the author, who obviously kept detailed notes to illustrate just how canny, courageous and ruthless Goenka was. Model Answer on distinction between Kidnapping and Abduction. Neither was available in India. He would meet and listen to all sorts of people. LSG vs RCB Live Score, IPL 2023: Spotlight on Kohli as Royal Challengers Bangalore aim to bounce back vs Lucknow, Honda's upcoming Creta-rival SUV could be called Elevate, to debut soon, Bhiwandi building collapse death toll rises to eight, Karnataka polls: BJP promises UCC, NRC, special police wing, Harry Potter fan creates art work depicting Benedict Cumberbatch as Voldemort, picture goes viral, Priyanka Chopra reveals why she looks up to Angelina Jolie: 'I think her choices have been so interesting', Kangana Ranaut supports same-sex marriage in India: 'Jab logo ke dil mil gaye hai, hum kya bol sakte hai'. Why should I mind? Wheelchair access in buildings is rare. Shourie jokes he was the only editor with the distinction of being sacked twice from the same newspaper. [20], After the defeat of the BJP in 2009 general elections, Shourie asked for introspection and accountability within the party. As the editor of The Indian Express, Arun Shourie received a tip-off by a person who was allegedly asked by Antulay to pay Rs 5 crore to open a hospital. But the teaching is, at that time, dont focus on the event. No. Closest to his daughter Nalini, he began to detach himself from her as well. Copyright Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. [6] He obtained his doctorate in Economics from the Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs at Syracuse University in 1966. Whether an order for further investigation u/s 173(8) CrPC can be passed post-cognizance ? The newspaperwas a central point for the government's attempts at censorship. They keep their personal battles and emotional agonies private. I happened to seeformer Union minister and politician-economist Arun Shourie's video interview with India Today in which he talks candidly about the sting of suffering in his life. And it takes 30 years to prepare. SHUBHAJIT ROY: You mentioned how the government doesnt value expertise. Atal Behari Vajpayee, when he became prime minister in 1998, made Arun Shourie a Rajya Sabha MP and a minister, managing disinvestment and revolutionising Indias telecom industry. Also Read: Nirmala Sitharaman interview: Fight us in House, attract smaller parties, keep us under watchbut Cong moving further to fringe. He speaks syllable by syllable. We didnt know what to do. Behind the barbed-wire writings is a man with a cause, a solitary chronicler holding up the mirror to degenerate political values. he asks. For instance, the lies on social media or Republic TV. . He is often told that he has set an example to others. His alertness is intellectual but also practical: his wife Anita, who has Parkinsons disease, and his son Aditya, who has cerebral palsy, are both upstairs, and they may need his help at any time. Which has it been for you? All Rights Reserved. If and when science overcomes suffering, it would cease to be worth living as human beings thereafter. Shourie speaks fondly of his mother-in-law, Maltiji, who looked after Aditya for 25 years despite her crippling arthritis. It is how one copes with suffering and, as you say, "transmutes" it - in the alchemy of the soul - into enrichment and encouragement for one's species as a whole. My only claim in sharing these words with you is that I too have walked the via dolorosa of life. Suffering is intensely personal. Former Justice (J S) Verma, who was the author of the collegium system, had said that it has become a bargaining place On the other hand, if you give the Executive, like the current assertive one, greater authority, you will have an even more disastrous judiciary. SHYAMLAL YADAV: What is your view on the RSS? She was around 42 at the time..," Shourie looks back in time. This was because the readers felt that it was not just their (the medias) voice which is being choked, my voice is being choked. I wish you would share yourself with us more often. The perspective suddenly changes with the awareness that "father" is god, he says. ANANT GOENKA: Do you think that people today care about free speech and free press as they used to 10-15 years ago? It has taught me that it is a privilege to suffer. But when you age, someone else will decide what you wear and where you go. One does also wonder when the author expounds at great length on his past investigations, whether 35 years down the line, a younger generation is really interested in knowing every last detail of corruption scandals of yesteryears, when the political situation has since undergone a sea change. You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. Sometimes, one doesnt need this exercise of emotional telepathy (or in other words, stepping into the litigants shoes). Arun Shourie with wife Anita, his mother, Dayawanti Devasher, and son Aditya, who's in the lap of his father, HD Shourie Arun Shourie 's new book is a rumination on death, and also makes sensational revelations about how his father timed his own demise. We bear false witness to ourselves and outrage our own conscience. It prompts him to question God's ways and infer a few eternal truths, which to the writer are strangely comforting. We had meetings from around 6-11 pm, and during that time he would show total focus. Arun Shourie pens down his trauma IANS | By HT Correspondent, New Delhi Jul 19, 2011 04:45 PM IST Arun Shourie pens down the strain of bringing up his disabled son and taking care of his. Are you an optimist? Why dont we do it ourselves?" [18] As Disinvestment Minister, he led the sale of Maruti, VSNL, Hindustan Zinc among others. As they absorbed the news, the kind doctor gave them what Shourie calls the "best piece" of advice anyone could offer: "I have not been to your country but from what I have heard, you have strong, well-knit families there. Political parties have reaped rich electoral dividends riding on his name. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. This was (former PM) Ataljis (Bihari Vajpayee) great quality. [23] He has said that, although he sees a danger from perceived Muslim violence such as the Godhra train burning incident of 2002, people have tended to redefine the "Hindutva" term. Yes, you and I have had differences of opinion in the past. Claimed by the government to be a reinforcement of India's constitutional secularism, it was widely criticised by both Muslims and Hindus. His world is music, family, family parties," says. But, Arun, your wife is, all that notwithstanding, so very privileged because she has a husband like you. Vir Sanghvi Wiki, Age, Wife, Children, Family, Biography & More. In 1975, during The Emergency introduced by the then prime minister, Indira Gandhi, Arun Shourie started working for the Indian Express against what he saw as an attack on civil liberties. How Suffering Refutes Religions. Even the normally sacrosanct courts were not exempt from his scrutiny and he would pore over and dissect judgments, astounding everyone with his intellectual arguments. So they can concentrate on one field of activity, for instance, becoming proficient in cyber warfare. Arun Shourie, minister in the previous NDA government, added depth and intellect to the Atal Bihari Vajpayee Cabinet. I wish only to request you to be available to a whole world of people - the broken, bleeding humanity - who need you, a little more than you may otherwise realise. He said, "the son of man has come to suffer and to die for others," and then he said, "The son of man has come, not to be served, but to serve" Spiritually suffering and service, as Arun emphasises, are inseparable. Jha criticized Shourie's book Eminent Historians, which concerned the NCERT textbook controversies, that it contains "slander" and "has nothing to do with history. Another was a sort of "reading rod" that was lighter and slimmer than a Braille book. I can never forget your dismounting from the rostrum to wheel up the mangled victims of leprosy to the stage, without even a distant shadow of revulsion. But another personal loss accelerated the spiritual journey. Parliament or a state legislature is not an abstract institution. ARUN SHOURIE: The appointment of the foreign minister (S Jaishankar) was a wonderful idea of Mr Modi. Arun Shourie isan Indian journalist, author, and politician who hasserved several decorative positionslike economist with the World Bankin two terms, a consultant to the Planning Commission, editor of the Indian Express, and Timesof India and a cabinet minister during 19982004. previous 1 2 next . The Aadhaar Bill and several other Bills were said to be money Bills. The problem is in this selection of persons who will be there. ARUN SHOURIE: The answer is all of these. He recalls how she would read him the news, stories, poems and rhymes. What kind of government says that we cannot pay compensation because we dont know how many migrants died? Modi has the power of Jesus he raises the dead: the Congress Party, the leftist intellectuals., Shouries devil-may-care attitude towards the conventions of public life may be conditioned by his personal circumstances. By punching a number on the keys, a blind user could call up the websites. Shourie is married to Anita, and they have a son. A spout would help. The compassion of the Buddha and personal suffering combined to script a religion of pain and redemption for journalist-politician-writer Arun Shourie, who recalls the trauma of bringing up his disabled son and taking care of his ailing wife in his new book. It transpired that Shourie's bedridden/wheelchair-bound wife had to somehow be taken to the Faridabad court, miles and miles away from their home in New Delhi, if she didn't want to face arrest . She used to be able to feed herself but her legs now flail so badly that one person has to hold her legs down while another feeds her. So, we should be humble. There was a wonderful sentence that Justice K Subba Rao (known for his dissenting judgments) had said, I am writing for the brooding sense of the future We should not have that much empathy for people. Before the Bihar elections, he described the NDA government as Congress plus a cow, and said that Prime Minister Modi was keeping silent on incidents like the Dadri killing while his colleagues stirred up trouble. Shourie had studied in India before going abroad in the early 1960s. But the problem is much deeper than just this regime. They were the readers Every time there was a raid on Ramnathjis house and on The Indian Express, the circulation went up. The relationship between Shourie and his proprietor was both close and stormy. Atalji gave me absolute latitude., Until recently, Shourie appeared to be on an inside track. And the third is one for which the country will pay for a very long time. Arun shourie, former union Minister, economist, journalist, author and social activist. As Disinvestment Minister, he managed the transaction of Maruti, VSNL, Hindustan Zinc among others. Similarly, for the inflation rate, I dont think its a wonderful thing for the RBI to just keep sticking out the number and twist all policies to accord with that particular number. Though trained as an economist, he left an indelible mark on Indian journalism with his insightful, well-researched crusading campaigns which, at times, changed the course of politics; brought about new legislation and focused public attention on governmental corruption. If they dont listen to the truth as you are portraying it, they will pay for it. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com. Section 292 IPC not attracted, rules the Supreme Court. Can gay marriage be part of Hindu cultu Can gay marriage be part of Hindu culture? But despite their style, the books are obviously the work of a brilliant man, with a wide if idiosyncratic learning, a pa s sion for the freedoms of speech and press, and a desire to get beneath current events to address underlying issues. This edition of Off The Cuff, which saw former minister and author Arun Shourie with ThePrint's Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta, was held in Chennai in July 20. Then cabinet secretary Vinod Pandey had relied on his blind faith in astrology to run the country. 12crore) of discretionary spending available to him under Members of Parliament Local Area Development Scheme (MPLADS) to setting up of Bio-Sciences & Bio-engineering Department at the Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur. His wife, Neelam Jolly, owns and runs an NGO, Vishwas, which is supported by a lot of renowned people in the media industry such as Arun Shourie, Lord Meghnad Desai, among many more. You are more than a compensation for all she has lost. Political leaders, stalwarts who died in 2020. Hyundai's Creta EV spotted on another test run. P VAIDYANATHAN IYER: Externally, the country is grappling with China. What to expect. He has got all provincial leaders and key persons in districts in his hands. He has also been named International Editor of the Year Award and was awarded The Freedom to Publish Award. ARUN SHOURIE: First is the complete throwing away of all norms. Arun Shourie with his son Aditya, 35, who has cerebral palsy, a condition that disrupts the 'wiring' between the brain and the rest of the body. Adit cannot walk. asthe son of the Punjabi couple Hari DevShourie and Dayawanti Devasher. He can see only from the left side of his eyes. [1] He developed a reputation as an intelligent, fearless writer and editor who campaigned for freedom of the press, exposed corruption and defended civil liberties such that, in the words of Martha Nussbaum, "his dedication to the truth has won admiration throughout the political spectrum". Yet Shourie and Anita have travelled all over India with their son; eating out in restaurants is one of Adityas great loves. "You are the one, who brought misery into our home. It is because suffering broke and expanded my soul (how else can the soul be expanded?) ARUN SHOURIE: There are two very distinct ways. If you see the falsehoods which have been uttered, I think they are exceeded only by (US President Donald) Trump. It means that he wants it to be done fast, like the one who has a beard, Suman!, Does Arun Shourie mind being thought of as a maverick? Simultaneously, between 197274, he was a consultant to the Indian Planning Commission and it was around this time that he began writing articles as a journalist, criticising economic policy. Thats true. His idea of development is to have a few large projects like the Sardar Patel statue, which turns out to be made in China, or a bullet train from Ahmedabad to Mumbai, rather than spend that money to improve the speed of all trains in India by 15 mph. He was active, both mentally and. He knows hes the king. But those sitting as law ministers today were supposed to reverse course. For somebody like you, who has been a crusader against corruption, how are you dealing with it? Every day I was carrying Anitas milk to him in a test tube.. Critics of Shourie who view him as a hypocrite, a betrayer, a sour man angry not to have been given a job in government, may underestimate his obstinacy. The way is to prepare for much greater violence in the future. And ideology is always an instrument for domination. Shourie says that these gadgets make a big difference to people. When Shourie asked her what purpose it could serve since Aditya was never going to use it, she replied: "But just see his sense of achievement when he gets the answer right.". Growth is a besieged deity, was the opening sentence. Showing 30 distinct works. We talked about black money, national security, banking. Ambedkar has come to be idolized as no other political leader has. It is being able to implement that in useful projects in the future. Dressed plainly, a pen and a pair of reading glasses in the breast pocket of his shortsleeved linen shirt, Arun Shourie looks nothing if not alert. "If Adit has to be toileted, then focus only on lifting him out of bed and toileting him," he writes. Continue readingFor 24x7 updates on Mumbai and Maharashtra. One lakh of each sureties for Arun Shourie were his old colleague Jaswant Singh's son Manvendra Singh and his wife Chitra Singh. This enables the people to change the norms. Photos: Winners of the 67th National Film Awards. He cannot stand, he cannot use his right arm. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Answer Writing Exercise(CPC-1) Broad Guidelines for a Model Answer. [23], With the exception of Mahatma Gandhi, he has little time for any religious thinker and, says Nussbaum, his books "nowhere seek to provide balance; nowhere is there a sense of complexity. And so we should not think of the two traditions as either/or. ARUN SHOURIE: The institutions are the persons who man them at that particular time Individual judges have changed the course of justice in the Supreme Court Institutions are not something abstract, they are the individuals who man them. I dont give a damn So that is the culmination of a long process. Shekhar Gupta With His Wife Neelam Jolly Career Shekhar started as a cub reporter in 1977 in The Indian Express, Chandigarh. We have to work hard at it. Or is it not as high as it was in their priority list? He is wearing a hat and mittens, ready to be taken out for a walk. Situations change and we should not be stuck on a particular number. I thank my friend: PM Modi to Bill Gates for appreciating Mann Ki Baat. This, he warns, is what the Auschwitz survivor, the psychiatrist Viktor Frankl, termed "the delusion of reprieve", seen in captives who convince themselves, on the thinnest wisp of hope, that, somehow, they will be selected to live. Over the last couple of decades, B.R. India's No. His world is music, family, family parties. What led to the violence in Manipurs Churachandpur before CM N Biren Singhs visit? Actually, there was no farm house and she was finally exonerated from all charges. He wasawarded the Ramon MagsaysayAward in 1982. Book reviews, festivals and all things literary. I thank you, Arun, for being such a husband. Talking to media, Arun Shourie said that CBI decided to register the case in August 2014 based on an anonymous complaint forwarded by Finance Ministry . Who can disagree with Arun here? Perceptions vary when seen from different angles and Shourie sometimes suffers from tunnel vision. Arun Shourie on his days at The Indian Express, what's changed since then, what's new about the current establishment, the media's challenges and the weakening of institutions. Here a few take-aways/main themes/ideas from the book: The wheels of justice grind slow, but they grind exceedingly fine? VANDITA MISHRA: You said the crisis of institutions is not really a creation of one regime. And he certainly would be among the persons who would know these things You dont just have to have an expert, you have to give the expert the confidence I want to listen to your independent advice.. From the start, he and Anita incorporated Aditya and the consequences of his disability into their lives, supported by their families. Is there such a thing as painless love? Watch, Man takes out fritters from boiling oil with bare hands, netizens ask if chefs have superpowers, Watch: Tiger steps aside for elephant herd, people are reminded of a scene from The Jungle Book, Vinesh Phogat at Idea Exchange: When women raise their voices, they are targeted first, Tim David's wild ride: Rejected by Western Australia, moved to Singapore, now an X-factor for Australia and Mumbai Indians. One doesn't have to age, these days, to have our spine give away under the burden we carry. He was later to return to India, where he would become a cabinet minister, prolific author and newspaper editor, who fought corruption and campaigned for press freedom during his time at The Indian Express and The Times of India. VANDITA MISHRA: In your book, one of the underlying themes is how one can turn adversity in their favour. Yet he laughs you can hear his laughter three houses away. Aditya looks at me and raises his left arm. Today, the RSS middle leadership has been completely co-opted by the government apparatus. The First Chapter relates to Arun Shourie's bed ridden wife - Anita's case: of her trials and tribulations when she finds herself as an accused in a trial, for having constructed a farm-house in violation of environmental regulations. He worked there for 6 years and resigned in 1983 to join India Today as a reporter. 'I can no longer escape my nightmares', is Andrew Tate hinting at having panic attacks? (HarperCollins). And the way the Supreme Court has been conducting itself in many cases and the sense of their priorities They can find time for Arnab Goswami or (late actor) Sushant Singh Rajput, but not for Kashmir or migrants? Arun Shourie worked inthe office of the Minister of Disinvestment, Communication and Information Technology in the government of India. So people may fool themselves and then pay for the consequences. And China is a disruptive power. I was surprised, because I wasnt a party member. And why have journalists missed the trend? Nobody can know everything So to make it a practice to stay away from all expertise and push out anybody who is regarded as an expert, opens not just the regime but the country to great danger. While we are talking, Aditya Shourie appears in his wheelchair. ARUN SHOURIE: Mrs (former PM Indira) Gandhi had many redeeming qualities, for instance, a sense of shame That is missing in the rulers of today. Read 15 years of Mumbai Mirror's journalism here. sort by. Much of the book is a meditation on whether the major religions can offer an explanation as to why innocents should suffer, hence the subtitle. The day his son was diagnosed with cerebral palsy, Arun Shourie was working as an economist with the World Bank in Washington. Arjun Kapoor seems to be a fan of Turkish eggs; heres why you should have them too, IPL 2023 in 360 VR: Immerse yourself in the action with JioDive VR Headset. Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. Journalist, politician, and author Arun Shourie has worn many masks. He was honoured with the Padma Bhushan by the UPA Government in 2009 for his contribution to journalism. [31], Minister of Communications and Information Technology, Minister of Communications & Information Technology, Minister of Development of North Eastern Region, Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs, Indian Council of Social Science Research, The Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act 1986, Members of Parliament Local Area Development Scheme, The Ayodhya Reference:Suprema Court judgment and commentaries, "Nalini Singh's daughter Ratna writes novel about mother-daughter troubled relationship", God's an invention to suit society's needs: Arun Shourie, "Interview with Arun Shourie Decentralised Emergency in India By Srikant Kottackal translated by A J Philip senior journalist and columnist", "Arun Shourie on what to do and not to do in the final lap of life", "Arun Shourie's Speech on Media Freedom at Press Club of India: Full Transcript", "Arun Shourie says pressure to change electoral system should come from society-Politics News , Firstpost", "How History Was Unmade At Nalanda! receptionist job in alambagh, lucknow, toe touch weight bearing on stairs,